Facebook Marketplace stirs up old dreams

Posted on May 14, 2007. Filed under: Uncategorized |

So today the day finally came when facebook launched their marketplace. While the launch of FB marketplace wasn’t particularly surprising my reaction to it has been. As you probably know I was a co-founder of boso.com, the first attempt at a national marketplace for students in the UK (and from everything I’ve seen, still the most succesful one by some distance). However it’s coming up to four months now since Kul and I decided to change direction and get out of the student marketplace space and until the online auction space with auctomatic. So with that in mind the release of FB does not impact on me in any way at all (so long as they stay out of building tools for eBay sellers I’ll be fine). However I still can’t stop thinking about it and on some level it still feels like being punched in the gut and here’s my attempt at explaining why (and then I’ll talk about what I think FB marketplace means for the student classifieds sector).

So boso did quite simply change my life. If it wasn’t for starting up boso while at university, I wouldn’t have seen how amazing doing a start up is and things may well have worked out very differently. It’s not surprising then that I had a HUGE amount of emotional attachment to boso – who doesn’t get attached to their first start up? Even though it’s no longer the project I’m working on when I saw facebook marketplace, my initial reaction was still the same as if boso was still my life. I suppose that by virtue of doing a web start-up you have to accept the fact you’re always sailing pretty close to the wind. With such a low barrier to entry and big boys in the space you face a bewildering range of threats to your livelihood. I can imagine just how seriously it would have hurt to have seen FB marketplace if I were still working on boso and it’s something I guess you just have to face up to as an entrepreneur, sometimes the big boys can just decide to crush you.

The other thing that makes it all slightly surreal is actually seeing and using the facebook marketplace in real life. As facebook continued to grow we always knew it was a potentially serious threat. I reached a stage with boso where I had a quick comeback for any criticisms of the boso concept but the one I always knew I was fudging was “what would you do if facebook did this?”. So after expending latent mental energy on trying to answer that question (if only to myself) now actually seeing it as a living breathing entity is strange.

Having the relief factor of not being in the space is obviously comforting but in a way that’s just coincidental this time around. There’s a seriously big chance that next time I won’t be lucky and it’ll actually be my livelihood being threatened by someone. If that day comes then I’ll have to decide whether to knuckle down and get ready for the fight or call it a day.

One thing I won’t do is start remaining “emotionally detached” from my startup. I’ve heard people give that advice before but that’s no way to run a startup. I do believe you need to reach a level of emotional balance where you’re not continually swinging high and low but that doesn’t mean you’re in any way detached. If I wanted to be emotionally detached I’d work in a bank. I want to do a startup so I can carry on dreaming (and executing on) changing the world in some way.

Anyway so my personal feelings aside, what do I think about FB marketplace itself? Well I don’t think it was always going to be an instant success. Norms of behaviour are important on the web and facebook has always been careful about which ones they promote. The reason I think marketplace will be massive now is because the users have started using it for that purpose. I’ve seen my friends start using facebook notes to list things they’re trying to sell or putting the names of items they want in their status updates. That’s not what they used facebook for a year ago (if marketplace had launched then I still think it would have been beatable but maybe my vision is a little clouded on this one) but that is what they’re using it for now. For me that was the final nail in the coffin and I’ve been expecting to see this development since.

As with all facebook features it’s been very slickly implemented and it’s hard to imagine how you’d compete with it (though I wish they’d make it easier to just see a whole facebook marketplace with all listings on facebook, marketplaces need to at least give the impression of liquidity and I’d be happier starting from the position of a generic marketplace and then drilling down into the networks I wanted rather than vice versa). You could try and focus on facilitating the trades themselves in a way that facebook couldn’t replicate but a lot of the sales will be low value items which are suited to quick and easy trades anyway.

What I might be interested to see is the potential for API spinoffs (assuming the developers who tried using the API to build their own classifieds solutions aren’t too disheartended of course). Maybe you could mashup ticket sales for events on facebook with the marketplace and make that trading experience better than facebook can, like StubHub did to eBay, though once you start getting into niches of niches you’re getting further away from big business.

As far as I’m concerned, sites like Chegg or DormItem (college classifieds) should stop trying to compete with FB and see if they can do something complimentary to the marketplace service. Otherwise they’re in big big trouble.


Make a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

3 Responses to “Facebook Marketplace stirs up old dreams”

RSS Feed for Meal Ticket Comments RSS Feed

what’s up bitch!
i saw your and kul’s picture in the newsweek article about ycombinator while i was procrastinating studying for finals. drop me a line the next time you’re in california – i live here now as i’m going to law school here and will most likely be in berkeley/SF in the summer. good luck with auctomatic…facebook expanding with a marketplace thing was pretty predictable, anyway, but they still have to compete with ebay. i was just thinking, that weebly site that got a lot more press in the article – those guys didn’t do anything new or original, they just improved massively on something that’s been around for a while – free web page tools. auctomatic is sort of similar (is your goal to get bought out by ebay? or, what if ebay simplifies their listing process?), so i think you’re on the right track…anyway, back to studying

Hey Harj, thanks for sharing this!

One thought I have is that as an Entrepreneur, one can’t afford to be naive or passive regarding potential competition. There has to be some sensible second-guessing and planning for likely moves by other players as part of the core strategy.

It seems to me that more care could be taken by current startups to avoid building businesses that can be snuffed in an instant by bigger players. Obviously you cant worry about this all day, and it’s just bad luck if out of the blue Google releases an app in your space (Kiko etc) but still..In the case of the FB marketplace, it was rumoured to be coming for a long time: users were already trying to post items for sale using the exisiting features (as you mentioned) and a quick survey of the top apps built with the FB api revealed the “classifieds” idea was common.

It seems to me that the question today should be not “is this the death of other marketplaces?” but “how effectively have FB implemented the feature/how have the other apps positioned themselves to differentiate?” Your post gives the impression that all facebook have to do is launch a feature and it instantly renders other apps without a chance.. 😛 Let me give the example of photo-sharing sites. Facebook is big for photos, but last I heard it hadn’t rendered Flickr/Photobucket etc obsolete!

Towards the end of your post you talk about how to avoid competing with Facebook, use of the API etc. I disagree with you here. Any site which “complements” or enhances the Facebook site is at risk of being copied/made redundant by improvements to Facebook itself. Trying to “compete” with another site simply by e.g. providing an “improved” view of the data is great for the users but not a sensible business – the site interface is such a superficial part of the whole and improvements can be copied by strong competitors with little effort.

API integration is cool, but if a site relies on a single third-party API or site for success then you’re treading on an extremely unstable footing. The APIs provide a great (free!) testing ground for the big sites to see what people want, what will be successful. Ultimately a company with plentiful dev resources like Facebook has a very low barrier to entry to creating new features itself. Remember that the ultimate reason for releasing an API for a site is to increase it’s own growth!

To become a success and minimise the risk, sites have to provide value when used themselves, or provide integration with *several* third-party sites, preferably adding additional functionality on top – more than just a “mashup”. This removes reliance on the whims of individual big players (like Facebook) from the long-term chances of success. An alternative is to target a different market (non-students)..

So, whats the risk factor with Auctomatic and the Ebay API? 🙂

Facebook market place great concept!! It is actually happening for me.

Where's The Comment Form?

Liked it here?
Why not try sites on the blogroll...

%d bloggers like this: